Was the Virgin Conception an Invention of Jewish Christians?

Reposting an interesting article concerning the virgin virth of Christ. Enjoy!

I’ve been writing lately about the “virgin conception” of Jesus. Is this an essential truth claim of ChristianityIs it reasonable Jesus could have been conceived in such a miraculous way? Was the “virgin conception” borrowed from mythologies that preceded Jesus? If the “Virgin conception” is true, why didn’t Paul mention itWhy didn’t Mark include it in his Gospel? Skeptics have assailed the claim on a variety of fronts. Some critics of the “virgin conception” argue that the earliest Christian authors of the Jesus “mythology” inserted this idea regarding His conception in an effort to give Jesus the “heroic” birth that was consistent with other Old Testament heroes.

Remember that the first Christians were raised within the Jewish culture and religious environment, and these first adherents were familiar with the birth stories of Isaac, Moses, Samson and Samuel; these characters had irregular and unusual births. Were the early authors of the New Testament canon simply trying to create a new hero in the tradition of other Jewish heroes who had unusual birth narratives? There are several reasons to reject such an accounting of the birth story of Jesus:

Continue Reading at Cold-Case Christianity with J. Warner Wallace.


Image from WallpaperCave.com

4 thoughts on “Was the Virgin Conception an Invention of Jewish Christians?

  1. It was inserted by the writer of ”Matthew” as supposed fulfillment of prophecy, and all it is is a hash job lifted from Isaiah in an attempt to give the already stupid story a measure of credibility – and failed miserably.

    I think you are beginning to scrape the bottom of the barrel with your choice of posts if you are stooping to post nonsense like this.


    1. Hello Ark!
      If Mathews motives is your strongest objection then your entitled to it. Luke also mentioned the Virgin birth. But since you view the bible as a fiction I have to wonder what motivates you to comment on a fiction everyday? What hope do you have?


      1. The motive of the writer of Mathew is exactly that – to demonstrate that Jesus’ birth is the fulfillment of prophecy; something every recognised biblical scholar attests to. When the true nature of the story began to be brought to light – that the prophecy was meant for King Ahaz – that apologists devised the duel prophecy.
        Do you not believe that Jesus’ birth is a fulfillment of prophecy?
        Are you unaware of Matthew Chapter 1 verse 22?
        Yes, or no?


  2. Furthermore ….

    the apostle Paul makes no reference to the virginal conception by the mother of Jesus when speaking of Jesus’ origins and divinity. His epistles were written during the 50’s A.D. and predate all of the four gospels. Although Paul never met Jesus (who died about 30 A.D.), he personally did know James, the brother of Jesus. Yet despite this eye-witness link to Jesus, Paul apparently knows nothing of the virgin birth, for he states only that Jesus was “born of a woman” (Galatians 4:4) and was “descended from David, according to the flesh” (Romans 1:3), thereby implying a normal birth.”


    I am truly baffled that a seemingly intelligent person as yourself would even consider the tripe of the virgin birth as having any credibility at all.

    Tell me, in all seriousness, when you study apologetics does this not include hermeneutics, language, etymology, and historical origins, or do you simply admit you are a sinner then latch on to every writer ( such as this half-wit Wallace) that can fuel your guilt-ridden beliefs?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s